Ep. 002

Why So Many Women Were Told “It’s Fine” | Menopause & HRT Truths

Dr. Tracy Neal, MD

April 13, 2026 · 59 min

Dr. Tracy Neal, MD, explains why she believes so many women in perimenopause and menopause were dismissed, and how she talks patients through hormone therapy.

Education only, not medical advice.

Chapters

Guest

Dr. Tracy Neal, MD

This transcript was produced by software and may contain errors.

Read the transcript

What I have heard the most from my hormone patients is that they went and asked somebody to check that whether it was a gynecologist, primary care, whatever, please check my hormones, and they were basically dismissed and offered an antidepressant. Well, Tracy, thank you for joining us on our second episode of Honest Dose Podcast. We're very delighted to have you here today. And I have this inside joke of how we met, right? It's if a pharmacist and an anesthesiologist walked into a longevity conference, that's how we met, right? That is how we met. No jokes, jokes all aside on bar jokes or whatnot. That's where we met about 11 years ago. And we've known each other for a little over a decade. Exactly. Worked together well, I would say, in that timeframe.

Yeah. And you were an anesthesiologist when we were going through that longevity course that we met at. Yes. I was a practicing anesthesiologist, had been in practice for 15 years or so. By the time I decided that I wanted to branch out, and I was like, I'm going to do this. And kind of relearn medicine from a root cause, as opposed to the boxes that we were taught in medical school. Yeah. So tell us more about that, right? Like what made you want to go from anesthesiology, which is a very highly coveted specialty in medicine, right? There are a lot of kids I speak to all the time. They're like, I want to go into dermatology or anesthesiology, right? To make a lot of money is literally what their answers are too. So what made you go from that to longevity medicine, which now is like a really, really cool specialty to be in, if you want to call it that. But 11 years ago, that was considered what, almost like folk medicine. I mean, I've heard it all, right? We've heard it all. It's like unstructured, no guidelines. Why are you doing that, right?

So what made you go into that? Well, you know, I'd always been passionate about health and wellness. And even through medical school, as I was learning the way they taught us traditionally, I was passionate about nutrition and diet and exercise and did a lot of different things as best as I could when time allowed. Sort of working on that aspect of health. We weren't being taught it, but I was passionate about it more on a personal level. And so, you know, as I practiced, saw hundreds, thousands of people with illnesses, et cetera, you know, it just, I started to wonder more and more, you know, I'm treating, I've got a patient coming in for surgery and we're fixing something. But every time I have a case for anesthesia, I had to assess head to toe, all the medicines they're on, all of their body systems. That's how I evaluated, you know, what I needed to do for the surgery. And it really, in the back of my mind, there were always the questions lurking, the how, the why. And then my own personal health, my mid, 30s, I had my thyroid failed. And intrinsically, I really felt like it was stress, that stress had done this to me. But there was really nothing, I had had a pregnancy the year before too. And we know that it does increase the incidence of thyroid failure. But, you know, I felt like long-term it was stress and then, and probably hormone related as well. But there was really nothing out there that was, that was correlating those things. And there was nothing in my traditional training. Putting those pieces together. And so I decided that I really wanted to learn more about the wellness space. Not really knowing I was going to relearn all of medicine, but it worked out well. Yeah. So you basically had this curiosity, right? Especially being well-trained, board certified in anesthesiology. You're like, these things are happening in my life. Yeah. But yet I don't understand what's going on.

Based on what I've learned. Yeah. But there's purely something chemical or something that medicine can't explain at the end of the day, right? It has to be explainable somehow. Exactly. So you just went on this journey. I did. Because I was, you know, the body is not just boxes of systems. It's all interconnected. And I, and I, and I wanted to know the why, the causation. You know, I didn't want to keep doing what modern medicine does, which is putting a Band-Aid, giving a medication for something, but not really going to the root cause. And so I, I, I wanted to learn root cause. That does lead us into a study that kind of just changed how hormone health is, was done in a woman, right? Absolutely.

That's the Women's Health Initiative. So let's kind of dive deeper into that. And as we all know, the FDA recently just announced how they're removing the black box warning that came out of that study back in 2003, which is a great win for everybody. Absolutely. Huge. Huge. Yeah. And we'll do a deep dive into that, but I'm just- I'm just setting the stage for, let's just give our audience a little breakdown of what the Women's Health Initiative was, what were the outcomes from it, and why did it set people back so far? Absolutely. So, you know, there's a, there are a lot of parts and pieces to the Women's Health Initiative that it's easy to go back retrospectively and say, well, you shouldn't have done this. You shouldn't have done that. So they were doing the best they could at the time, trying to forward medicine, trying to get some actual studies for, for hormone replacement. And part of the problem initially is that the age, they, the age of women that they included in the study was older. Yeah. It was an average of 63 years of age. Exactly. 63. Well, we know that the average age, women go into menopause between 45 and 55, average 52. We know that the real benefit of hormone replacement therapy is in the first 10 years after menopause. So if you've got an average age of 62, that is 10 years older. So there's that right there. You, they didn't really separate out also who had been on hormone replacement therapy before.

Also, one of the big things, they did a one dose fits all type dosing, and that is never going to be genetics factor into how we metabolize estrogen. There's your environment that factors into your diet, your, there's just so many things that factor into it that it can never be a one size fits all approach. The second thing is they were using synthetic hormones because that's all they had and they were dosing them orally and synthetic hormones are a big problem. And dosing orally for estrogen is specifically problematic. I'm going to pull out my little cheat sheet because I want to absolutely not get any of this. This is wrong. This is like critically important when we're talking about the side effects. So oral estrogen. Yeah. And just to give some more background for our audience, right? The Women's Health Initiative, the data came out in 2002, if I remember correctly. And it was a well-intended study. And the intentions were good, right? They wanted to see what the long-term effects of hormones were on women. Yes. It's just the way the study was structured.

Yes. Was the problem. Like you said, the average age of the person in the trial was 63, which is 10 years past what they should have been targeting, right? Yeah. They had a placebo group also that measured up against, which they didn't check to see if they were on hormone replacement therapy or not before. So there's all these factors that went into it where the study design was just very flawed. Exactly. We don't want to spend a whole lot of time getting into study design, but the major issues with it were what you're about to read. But they also used synthetic drugs. Correct.

Because that's what was available at the time. And it was a one-size-fits-all approach as well. Right. Right. So synthetic hormones, estrogen, and specifically oral estrogen, here is what it can cause. Hypertension, elevated, so high blood pressure, high triglycerides, increased liver enzymes.

It affects serotonin metabolism. So now we're talking mood, anxiety, depression, and increased risk of blood clots. Increased inflammation in the body, more carb cravings, hello muffin top, lower testosterone, again, now we're just doubling down on the muffin top, loss of muscle mass, feeling of well-being, and lower growth hormone, growth hormone being our main anti-aging compound in the body. For the synthetic progestins, increased appetite, weight gain, and fluid retention. So a lot of bad side effects from these synthetic hormones. And even more important, it can take three to six months for the body to get rid of synthetic hormones because it doesn't recognize them as it would bioidentical, which it thinks are its own hormones.

So if you're talking about the world, the Women's Health Initiative, you know, said increased risk of heart disease. Well, if you're taking oral estrogen synthetic, you're elevating blood sugar levels. Blood pressure, triglycerides, increased risk of blood. So is it causation or is it correlation? You've got an older subset that probably had some preexisting disease.

You've given them an oral estrogen that's elevating the risk factors. And so, you know, the result was scary, but it put a warning in place that really, for 20 years, took away the lifeline for women. Yep, 1,000%. And we have some data to back that up too, right? Yeah. So just to- Reiterate what you said. The side effects of synthetic hormones in general were all going to lead to these issues that you mentioned. And then you take an older population, right?

Right. And now you don't even recommend, if you're over 60 or 65, to start on these hormones. Absolutely. And that's the population they studied with these issues. Yeah. It was just bound to happen. But even the results were- So two things that came out of that study that just set things backwards, right? Was the increased incidence of breast cancer.

Right. Right? They claimed a 24% increase in breast cancer, right? Which is what scared the living hell out of every practitioner and woman on earth. Absolutely. Because that means that if you- The picture they painted was, is that if you're a woman and you go on any kind of hormone therapy, one in five of you are going to get breast cancer. Yeah. Right?

Which is scary. It is scary. And I would actually, if I didn't know any better, I would, if my mom tried to go on it, I'd be like, no, don't do it, right? So that's the picture that was painted. Yeah. And this is back in 2002 before, I mean, the internet was around, but the dissemination of information wasn't as fast. Correct. Right?

So a lot of factors here. Nowadays, if something like this comes out, TikTok's on it, and then people are trying to break things down. I mean, that's kind of the culture today. It's going to be debunked. Yeah. Yeah. It's debunked. The study would have been torn apart, analyzed every which way.

By every pundit out there, whether they're a pundit or not, right? Absolutely. So time also matters. But that 24% increase was also, it was an absolute increase, right? It's an absolute risk versus relative risk issue, which who's going to know what that is, right? And what they showed was that if you actually extrapolate that into actual real data for what would have actually happened, is that only one in 1,000 women would have got breast cancer. And that one person who got it, it was not mortal. It didn't lead to mortality rates going up.

So it was like, you got it, but then- It was traded. Exactly. Well, and you know, the other, I think a very interesting thing to think about is that we didn't have our full gene sequencing DNA information back then. We now know that there are genetic markers that people have that predispose them. We know that the environment can turn on and off genes. And so there were, none of that was taken into account, taken into effect.

They were doing the best they could at the time to try to get data. Yeah. But it is, you know. It's not a one-size-fits-all, and there are so many other factors that come into it. And I think that's part of what led to this, let's look at this again. Let's really break it down.

We've learned so much more now. It's long overdue that we take away this black box warning. Oh, yeah. I mean, absolutely thrilled that that's happening, right? So hopefully things start moving in the right direction, because once that study came out and the results were published in 2002, before that, right?

There's data on this. We had our analysts look up, aka interns, basically what showed that. We've been there, done that. Yeah, yeah, I know, right? You have to go through the whole pathway. Yes.

Basically, on average, one in three women who were qualified to be on hormone replacement therapy were on hormone replacement therapy before that study. So 33%, 35% was on it. After that study came out, just based on the decrease in sales of Prempro and Premarin as data points, it fell to 5%. Yeah. And, you know, statistics on menopause and menopause symptoms, 80% to 90% of women will experience symptoms during menopause. A third of women will have debilitating symptoms that affect their daily quality of life. And so if you think of it, a third of it, that sort of correlates with the number of women that were on hormone replacement therapy at the time. They got desperate enough that they, you know, they needed to do something.

And so that is a huge, huge, huge... Huge number of women that are suffering out there trying to basically tough through it with these incredible side effects. We talk now about, you know, estrogen is for bone health, brain health, and heart health, prevent heart disease. But there are so many other things that are side effects that truly can affect daily quality of life. Poor sleep, insomnia, weight gain, anxiety, depression, fatigue.

Vaginal dryness, loss of libido. You know, the list goes on. It's not just night sweats and hot flashes. And those things truly were affecting women's daily life. Yeah. And isn't it fascinating with all those things that were happening that are debilitating?

Nobody did anything about it. No. Like for 20 years or more, like 2025, 2002, 23 years later, right? Right. We are just now... We're moving this black box warning after so many people have been complaining from the top of the mountains about this issue and poking holes in the study that just set everybody backwards for like 20, 30 years, right?

And then now we're going to have to wait another 5 to 10 years before it becomes norm. Because guess what? There's few and far between medical practitioners who will educate themselves on this. And you just talked about how academia moves at the... At the pace they move. Yeah. And that's who's educating tomorrow's practitioners. That's right.

So like... Where are we going to stop the madness? Yeah, yeah. How do we get ahead of this, right? Like... Yeah. It is, you know, I have seen literally a handful of patients that their husbands were OB-GYNs. And they came to me for hormone help.

Because if you're a practicing OB-GYN out there and you're trying to deliver babies and see patients, and the office and keep your office afloat and deal with insurance and all of those things, you don't have time to go take a hormone course. And, you know, you don't even probably have the interest nor the energy levels. And so what I have heard the most from my hormone patients is that they went and asked somebody to check that, whether it was a gynecologist, primary care, whatever, please check my hormones. And they were basically dismissed and offered an antidepressant. Oh, yeah. We see that all the time, right? And that is the reality for women. So, Tracy, we just talked about how the WHI study showed a 24% increase in breast cancer, which is absolutely not...

Frightening. Yeah, frightening and not real, right? The data has shown that, you know, absolute risk versus relative risk. It wasn't taken into account. And plus, we also looked at the study that they did was flawed from a design standpoint. Yeah. So knowing this info, if a patient came to you and said, hey, I read about this, and it shows that if you go on hormones, you can get breast cancer, how do you talk to that patient? What do you walk them through?

So the first thing that I do is I explain what type of hormones are we using? How are we using them? So we're using bioidentical compounded hormones. We're using them in my menopausal patients on the skin. We're not doing anything oral. We're using our estrogen and progesterone in a cream on the skin. So it's not going into our bloodstream. It's not going through our liver.

Okay. Okay. So because we're using it that way, and we're testing in saliva, which is the tissues, reflects the tissue levels that are in the body, we use a very, very low dose. It is a fraction of the dose that they're giving, probably about a third of the dose of what would be given in an oral estrogen. So it's a very low dose. We're testing in actual tissues and looking at what the levels are. We always balance progesterone and estrogen. So I always have a ratio of progesterone to estrogen greater.

So I always have a ratio of progesterone to estrogen greater than 100. That is what's going to balance it and minimize any type of cancer effect. So low dosing, bioidentical hormones, testing every year when first starting, testing even more than that, and taking into account the overall health of the patient. I'm going to step out for a minute and give you my personal story of how I chose to do hormones because I have an incredibly strong family history of breast cancer. On my paternal side, my grandmother, my aunt, my first cousin, and my aunt and first cousin in their 50s passed away from breast cancer. So strong family history.

And it wasn't, well, the few genetic markers we knew back then. So we're talking 2013, 2014. That's when I went and did my wellness fellowship. Well, it just so happened that it coincided with my own personal menopause. So I'm now learning wellness medicine and I'm learning hormones. And, you know, you come into it with what you've been taught in medical studies. I'm not going to go back to medical school, but I've got an open mind now and I really, really am digging in. And it turns out that the first real things that we sunk our teeth into were hormones.

Thank goodness it wasn't cardiovascular. I might not have kept going through all the training. But, you know, so I've got a personal vested interest in it now. And I've got a family history, but I'm learning and I'm seeing the studies and they're presenting the data and they're talking about cognitive decline and bone, you know, bone health. And we all, as anastomists, as an anesthesiologist, I know the statistics. If a woman, an elderly, elderly woman breaks her hip, there is a 50% mortality and a 95% morbidity, meaning you will only 5% get back to the quality of life they had to begin with. With the mortality, morbidity and mortality. So mortality, that is going to shorten her lifespan.

She is half of those women. You will be able to directly correlate that hip fracture to death. Okay. So you're shortening time frame. Some of the older studies, the data was looking at like within a year or two. I think if you did a study now, the time frame may be a little different, but we're talking a huge, you know, and so when I talk about morbidity is getting your mobility back, you know, quality of life, daily living. What could you do before? What can you not do now?

Those sorts of things. So that's just bone health. Yeah. And basically where that all correlates to hormones is that. If you had a small fall, right, you shouldn't be breaking your hips. You should not. Because your bones should be strong enough to withstand that shock absorption, right? Exactly.

So because hormones are deteriorating and they're not treated during menopause or perimenopause, their bones are so brittle, it breaks faster. Osteoporosis and they're more at risk. Yeah. You know, and there's a sort of estrogen is not the only thing that we need for bone. Estrogen maintains bone density and protects against osteoporosis.

Progesterone actually helps build bone and testosterone helps strengthen bone. So we're talking, it's, you know, my favorite saying from our fellowship, the sort of guru of women's hormones, she would say it's a symphony of hormones. I love that. A symphony of hormones. You know, they all need to be working together. And so well-balanced hormone, and that's why I think, honestly.

Women's health has lagged so far behind men's health. I think that part of it is the complexity of women's health. It's not just a single hormone. It's multiple. Part of it is the complexity. Menopause is not a one-size-fits-all. It's different for everybody.

We're now realizing there's a perimenopausal period that, you know, for some people it's a short amount of time. But generally it's years leading up to menopause where hormones are becoming imbalanced and dropping. And so I think. Partly you had the people. It was easier to look at men's health and testosterone because it was a one-size-fits-all. It's testosterone.

Drug pharmacy, you know, your insurance covered testosterone, but they didn't want to cover women's hormones. And so there's so many factors that go into it. Yeah. And I'm going to take, I'm going to stick true to what our core value is for this podcast and just be really bluntly honest. Yeah. And just honestly say what you just said, right? Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I was trying to be politically correct. I know. I know.

But as, you know, even on the NIMBA side, as we're building these protocols out, right, we rolled out men before women. Yeah. And that is by design because here's the reality with women's hormones. It is not just one thing you're trying to treat and work on, right? It is a constant effort of balancing because so many things change throughout even the weeks that affect hormones. Right. And now you're not just dealing with just testosterone. You're looking at, or cortisol and testosterone.

Yeah. You're looking at estrogen, progesterone, testosterone, cortisol, right? Yeah. And the symphony needs to be managed by somebody. It does. Really well to get the maximum outcomes, right? And if you don't do it, that is the problem. If you don't actually manage the symphony well, guess what?

You've got an angry woman on your hands. Yes, you do. And nobody wants to deal with a very angry woman. Right. Who is unhappy. And then they offer them an antidepressant. Yes.

So, like, it is some work to balance it out because somebody needs to be subject matter experts like you who understand it to go in there and be like, you know what? You are in this time of stress in your life, right? That stress is pulling from your cortisol. Absolutely. And that's throwing this thing off and this thing off. Let's do this, right? Right.

One, we know medical professionals don't get enough training on this. So, how do, I mean, there's such a big disconnect, right? To be the, I don't know, what are they called? The symphony masters at the orchestra? Right. The orchestra, right? The orchestrator, if you want to call it. The conductor.

The conductor. The conductor at the symphony. You have to be well-versed in what you're doing. And I think, just speaking on my personal experience, I think AI can do a lot of that. And we're trying to do that at Nimbus, right? They can help physicians stay on track and manage this orchestra a little bit better. But that's the biggest reason, right? That's why doctors just like, you know, I know what's going to come down with this and I don't get paid enough to do this.

That's right. So, I am just going to give you Sertraline. Yeah. Or Zoloft. Zoloft, right? Right. And call it a day. Exactly.

That should take care of your vasomotor symptoms. You won't be bothering me for a while. Right. And they don't get paid to do that either, right? No. In a normal primary care practice, like, setting.

And I can go on about this and what's happening in primary care. Oh, yeah. I mean, that's a whole different conversation for another day about these VC companies coming in. Right. And now I have PCP friends who are like, I got to see 30 to 35 patients a day where I don't get paid. I don't have 20 minutes to sit and listen to all the symptoms that are happening. Which is what it requires. It does.

To get to the, it's like you're investigating, right? Well, and also, again, if you're just giving everyone the same dose, that's not going to work for everyone. Yes. And so, that's where you're, you know, maybe that same dose works for 30% of the people. But that's leaving 70% that are having issues.

And, you know, now you're getting phone calls. You're getting emails. You're getting patient portal messages. And that's, you're drowning already in trying to keep your practice alive. Yes. That is fundamentally what is happening. It's not that physicians don't care. No.

It's not that they don't know that this issue is happening because they do see, I mean, the black box warning just got removed, right? But these are the issues I see just from where we're sitting of how long it's going to take to change that. Yeah. Just because the FDA took out the black box warning does not mean shit, really, to be honest. And also remember, bioidentical compounded are not covered by insurance. It's not. So, back when I first started doing my wellness practice, you know, I actually got on the phone with a couple of insurers. Like an insurance company.

Well, we cover the hormones, but we don't cover the base that it's in. Well, the base that it's in is what allows it to absorb deep into the tissues and deliver it. And so, you know, my answer was, well, what do you want me to do? Sprinkle it on my patients like fairy dust? You know? Yes. Yeah. And so, that's, you know, that's the other thing is there's a cost involved if we're doing bioidentical compounded, keeping dosing individualized.

And, you know, for a lot of people, that makes it. Not reachable for them. Yeah. I mean. Going back to just the drugs even, right? Testosterone. Yeah.

Not even indicated by the FDA for women. No, for women. Right. And this is what testosterone does in the body. We talked about strengthens bone and muscles and promotes muscle tone, decreases excess body fat, helps keep skin from sagging, increases energy and libido, and enhances our sense of well-being.

Women need their testosterone. We don't need much. It is a very small dose. But we need some. It's a symphony of hormones. And so, if you're missing that piece of it, and you're still just focusing on estrogen and progesterone, you've missed a piece. Exactly. It's a symphony.

I love that. I'm going to start using the symphony part. That is a great analogy. Yeah. And, you know, there's reasons why there's not a drug that's coming out with the FDA indication. And, you know, as everything's unfolding in the GLP-1 world right now, I'm getting these questions about what does FDA indication actually mean? Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. What does FDA approved actually mean, right? Right. We'll have to do another podcast on that whole thing. Yeah. All together. You know more about that than I do. Oh, I know way too much about what the FDA does and what they can't do.

Yeah. But, unfortunately, for 99% of the population, FDA approval means something. Right. And it's not what they think it is. Right. Right. The government is full of a lot of redundancy and bureaucracy and, you know, and efficacy, like being effective and being and reacting to things in a... And a prompt, appropriate, is just, it's not there.

Yeah. It's not there. And I, too, and I, and I, we can understand why, right? Right. Because they're working on the population.

Right. Statistics. Yeah. So, we work in the world of personalization based on each person. They have to think of the 340 million Americans, right? Exactly. The greater good. Yeah.

The greater good. But that doesn't mean what we're doing is wrong. No. Right? And, like I said, 10, 12 years ago when we got into the space. Yeah. Right? It was looked upon.

And frowned upon. It was. But, you know, I learned what I learned. And I took my personal situation and I thought, you know, I believe what I've learned. I believe in the long-term health.

I believe in longevity and wellness. I'm going to do the hormones. I don't think that, you know, I can see that the stress has just, I don't have anything left. I'm going into early menopause. You know, I rely on my brain. I need, I can't, I can't have cognitive decline.

And I had, my dad had, you know, strong family history of heart disease. My dad had a quadruple bypass in his early 50s. You know, so heart disease.

Yeah. So, you know, I just. You took it up on yourself. I did. I, you know, I looked, I looked at all the data. I did the learning. And I decided, I did a risk-benefit analysis. And it was clear to me that the benefits clearly outweighed the risks.

Yeah. And I'm glad you did. And I'm glad we met 10 years ago when we walked into that bar. No, I mean. Yeah. Longevity conference. And I've actually been. I've been on hormones now for 13 years.

The way I prescribe hormones is what I have personally been doing for 13 years. Yeah. And you've influenced my philosophy on hormones too quite a bit. Even our Intel Health AI. Well, a lot of the trainings for the model is based off of how you treat a patient. So it's all based on real, real, real time data. So we appreciate that. Yeah.

So we talked about what you would say to that patient who comes, who has a fear of breast cancer. Right. Right. But in general, since you've been doing this for over a decade now. Yeah. Right. What does the average woman's protocol look like? How do you approach that?

If you're in, you know, you're just starting menopause. If you're looking at our average demographic, 45 to 50 years of age, 52 is when things kind of start for menopause. What does that treatment plan for that patient look like? So when we first talked and you said to me, hey, do you want to work with Nimbus and do women's hormones? And I was coming from a background of my wellness. I looked at everything head to toe. I mean, it was a 15 page lab report, cardiovascular factors, immune factors, a few genetic markers, full thyroid panel with antibody. I mean, it was exhaustive.

I came fresh out of fellowship and was like, I'm going to do these wellness things for patients. And I was used to assessing head to toe for surgery. But when you start assessing head to toe for the whole body, it is far more complex. So. You know, I was testing myself. I was looking at what was happening with me. I was having a wide assortment of patients, men, women, young women, even. And stress, cortisol is just so such a huge factor.

So I was just I was seeing women in their 20s that were coming to me. They weren't ill, but they weren't well. And their stress had basically stolen away their progesterone. So their calming sleep hormone was gone.

Most doctors like myself trained, you know, I was I went to a top medical school. I I loved my medical. I wouldn't I would go back to the same medical school. It was amazing. But we were trained a certain way.

Most of us don't realize that cholesterol is the building block for hormones. Hormones are made progesterone, estrogen, testosterone and cortisol. Our stress hormone are made from conversions of cholesterol down the pathogen. And this is happening in these pathways. Why is that important? It's super important because first of all, if your hormones are low, what is your body going to do to fix it is going to make more cholesterol. So we're looking at a cholesterol number in the lab for women that are peri menopause or menopause and it's up and we want to put you on a statin right away.

Hold the phone, we need to look at hormones because the body's trying to fix itself. Second of all, if you're under stress, you are going to disrupt your hormone symphony balance. you are going to upset the apple cart because in the conversion of hormones we start with cholesterol we go to pregnenolone which is the mother hormone hormone of memory and then we go down two different pathways the one pathway is dhea and then estrogen and testosterone the other pathway is progesterone and then cortisol our stress hormone well cortisol is our stress hormone it's also fight or flight survival and the body is designed that if it senses its endanger and it needs to run away from the lion and find the cave in the jungle it shuts down all hormones and everything goes to cortisol it's called cortisol steel yep what's the first thing that cortisol steals progesterone because it's the closest thing well let's talk about what progesterone does in the body balances estrogen huge builds bone has a complex body and it's the closest thing to the body it's the closest thing to the body effect enhances mood and sleep helps manage blood sugar thyroid function mineral balance regulates fluid balance and progesterone helps decrease the risk of endometrial cancer may protect against breast cancer so there's a lot of there there's a lot to unpack there yes there is a lot to impact there so let me start with one of my favorite topics you just talked about okay the cortisol steel yeah right so let's talk about the cortisol steel more which is which is basically what i see a lot of too in our demographic just because people are stressed all the time so if um 39 year old woman comes in right not in menopause we see this a lot in nimbus too when i started this business a long time ago it was i thought it was going to be all 52 55 year old females coming in buying test kits wanting yeah most of my patients are in their 40s yes and what we saw was you know menopause and menopause and menopause and menopause and menopause and menopause and menopause it's you said it really well earlier it's that it's not that they're in menopause they're it's not that they're ill right they don't feel well they're like i'm not myself anymore i'm not myself i'm edgy i'm anxious i'm not sleeping well i'm depressed i'm gaining a lot of weight in my midsection retaining water i'm retaining water i you know i just i'm snapping at my kid i just i'm i'm fatigued i'm on edge i'm on it i'm on edge right and i know this isn't me yes i know this is not me i can't figure out what's going on with me right that is a common trend and i've asked somebody to check my my hormones and they kind of blew me off and they're like you're too young and here's an antidepressant yes that's what happens unfortunately yeah but that same demographic that mom if you want to call it because that is the common demographic we see cortisol steel what's happening there just walk us through in layman terms of you know your stress when you're stressed what is exactly happening so cortisol just to geek out a little bit i'm going to talk about cortisol just for a minute cortisol has we don't want to give it a bad name it's vital for our body oh yeah cortisol is in charge of two parts of our body the one part is our daily circadian rhythm between seven and nine every morning our body puts out a nice big well it should put out a nice big burst of cortisol it's like your body's natural cup of coffee in the morning get up and go yeah between seven and nine a.m then it drops off significantly by mid-afternoon and it needs to be at its lowest by night so you can go to sleep because too much cortisol your mind's not going to shut down going to disrupt your body and you're not going to be able to sleep sleep and then the next morning it happens all over again so that's circadian rhythm cortisol the other way cortisol works is danger danger fight or flight you something stresses you out and you your body reacts by you know it what it does is it puts more glucose in the bloodstream because you need that to run faster from the lion to escape and make it to the case the lion analogy is so good right because it just makes sense you see a lion when you're just walking you're like oh yeah you've got a lion you've got a lion you've got a lion you've got a lion you've got to run to the cave but we weren't designed that five minutes later you left the cave and went looking for the puma and the jaguar and the tiger yeah we were designed that we stayed in the cave we let our adrenals which is what makes the cortisol we let our adrenal glands and our stress whole access settle down the brain the adrenals it all settled down and then you were at baseline again and then you cautiously left the cave that is not modern day life stresses are coming at us left and right and then you're in the cave and you're in the cave and you're in the cave and as we get more and more stress the body the brain can't really differentiate anymore is this a lion or is this just a kitty cat is this like a little kitten everything feels like danger and our adrenals ramp up and we start making more and more cortisol we start dysregulating our blood sugar our metabolism we start packing on the midsection weight we start getting inflammation in our body because cortisol let's talk about what cortisol does in the body increases energy and metabolism and it's a really good thing because cortisol increases energy and metabolism it's our i would i call it the spark plugs of our body thyroid being the engine cortisol being the spark plugs helps us respond yeah helps us respond to stress trauma and infection helps regulate blood pressure and blood sugar reduces allergic and inflammatory responses so there's a connection to the immune system interacts with progesterone when you have cortisol surges from stress it blocks progesterone receptors so let's back up for a minute it steals progesterone first and it blocks receptors it's a double double whammy yeah okay and when cortisol is elevated you thyroid hormone cannot get converted to the active form this is why my thyroid failed in my mid-30s i thought intrinsically i felt intuitively knowing my body i was like it's stress but there was nothing that supported that and then i did the wellness fellowship 10 years later and i was like okay i'm going to do this i'm going to do this i'm like bingo there it is that was the aha moment the aha moment so cortisol is not evil it's it's anti-inflammatory it's doing tons of things in the body it's only a problem when we have prolonged stress levels and it goes high and then eventually the body just can't keep up and then we end up in adrenal fatigue because our body can't make the cortisol anymore now we've got a brain fog inflammation um you know fatigue aches and pain i mean we are we are down and out we're hurting so there's this other side of the symphony that's happening with estrogen so what what's happening there yeah so basically and you know we stress cortisol that could be at any age and because progesterone is our most susceptible hormone if you're in your 20s and for instance you're in medical school and you know you've got stress upon stress upon stress you're going to end up losing and especially depending how your adrenals run um personally my whole life i'm lucky they haven't basically shut down but yeah i've had cortisol steal my whole life um and so progesterone it's not that i had too much estrogen it's that i didn't have enough progesterone to balance it what that leads to is estrogen dominance so estrogen dominance can happen it just means that there's not enough progesterone to balance the amount of estrogen in the body so even menopausal women can have estrogen dominance because they've still got more estrogen than they do progesterone so it's either estrogen too high or progesterone too low the end result being that the ratio of estrogen to progesterone progesterone estrogen is off that ratio should be greater than 100 and that is one of the markers we follow when we do our labs we treat to make sure that we get the progesterone to estrogen ratio above 100 that is why i feel so common giving all my patients hormones not worrying about cancer because balancing it we know we've got the right amount and that's why we call it hormone optimization or hormone balancing right because we need these tunes to be firing off at the same amplitude of whatever you want to call it right right so estrogen and progesterone need to be at a certain ratio correct to be in balance yes and that ratio gets upset by stress um and then that ratio gets upset during perimenopause and menopause so you know we talk about menopause all the time and everyone we make it sound like it's this thing that happens and it's the same for everyone and menopause is a process and that's why we now have the term perimenopause so the body will slowly but surely whittle away the hormones estrogen being preserved always till the last until it absolutely cannot do as much estrogen as it did before because it's the most vital of the hormones it's reproduction but if the body has to choose between cortisol survival and estrogen it's going to cortisol and it's not doing estrogen estrogen has over 400 functions in the body oh boy reproduction being one yeah so estrogen is critical and so the body will preserve it as long as they can so what happens is you know any anyone with a lot of stress in their body can end up with estrogen dominance they're going to start here are the symptoms because i think this is tell us the symptoms when do i need to worry when do i need to look at things when do i need to check so here are the symptoms of estrogen dominance this is where you're probably losing some progesterone you're either super stressed and like in your 20s or 30s or you've reached about 40 and now you're starting to hit the perimenopause pms heavy periods painful periods headaches low libido bloating mood swings fatigue anxiety depression breast tenderness and weight gain this is i think there's a lot of women out there that can relate oh yeah to these and they're not even close to menopause yet and we can we have the data on this right and yeah i know this is a lot of women out there that can relate to these and they're on the nimbus platform right we first one of the first questions about what are your symptoms why are you here yeah and these are typical things that surprisingly i've seen in a age group that i did not expect it exactly like like you said the 25 to 35 year olds going through this at that point in life is just wild it's wild it's wild and you know the biggest thing is if you want to try to help that person which mainstream doesn't want to you really need to do it as naturally as possible you need to sync it with their cycle you don't want to overtake anything you want to restore it naturally but here's the thing if we just look at hormones we're missing the root cause we haven't fixed her i can give my 25 year old patient who's in law school a progesterone capsule but if i haven't looked at her adrenal glands and her cortisol and supported that i have put a band-aid on it i haven't fixed it you're basically going back to cortisol steel just fueling in that basically it's like a pot yeah and the pot is has holes yeah you're putting more water into it but the holes keep increasing because you're not plugging up the pot well so my best analogy that's a great one i might have to remember that so my best analogy when i try to describe to patients is think of each of these hormones in the cascade as like a it's a waterfall and there it's a cascade of waterfalls and each of these waterfalls if one of them gets empty or lower level it can't go to the next level yeah it's depleted and so now we're we're that part of the hormone cascade right that's yeah this chemistry you need all the buckets to be full and overflowing for the cascade to cascade so buckets right well i'm honest i had a professor back at ut who used buckets to explain his name sal sasansky legend um he used to use buckets to explain pharmacokinetics because that's what pharmacokinetics is how fluid flows from xyz right but getting back to the subject of this this population that we did not expect right to have these issues the issues you just talked about yeah what's your advice for them where should they start yeah is so you know we like we just said prior to that when you asked me about doing women's hormones i said i will do hormones i will check hormones but i have to check besides the big three i have to check dhea because it's an intermediary that helps buffer some estrogen and testosterone from stress it's also great for the body anti-immune anti-aging and it's also great for the healthy weight um so it's got a lot of other important functions too but it's part of the hormones so if i'm going to look at hormones i also need to look at dhea um it's a supplement not prescribed but i most of my patients any kind of stress dhea is dhea is important it they described it as the second sort of fountain of youth uh in the hormone fellowship and i need to look at cortisol because it's running the show so if i don't check your cortisol i definitely haven't gone to root cause i haven't you know and then i need to check your thyroid because fatigue is such a common symptom for women and your thyroid is your engine of your body your adrenals are your spark plugs your adrenals are also running hormones if i just look at hormones i am truly not going to root cause and i'm going to a band-aid and i'm i'm not going to fix you so that is why our panel consists of what it does yeah and because we can go to root cause that's what you would suggest is a good starting point for somebody who is observing or having these symptoms you just talked about yes start with the test kit especially like a saliva test kit because you can get cortisol levels from it and so on right and that's why our test kit we go between seven and nine i told you that's when quarter cortisol does our big cup of coffee yeah so in that big sort of burst i can see are you just barely blipping are you bursting through the roof yeah or are you in my nice green realm yeah and we're using your expert experience you can see how much of adrenal fatigue you're actually in based off those bursts right yeah that's where that clinical or are you staying high adrenals all the time and you know totally blocking your thyroid leading yourself to some thyroid failure it's just fascinating um i i when i talked to rich yesterday about this about testosterone specifically and how testosterone is viewed upon as this bodybuilding hormone it's really not hormones are just chemical messengers in your body they are chemical messengers at the end of the day and even dhea something that sounds so simple which is a supplement yeah it has a much effect or power i take it daily as estrogen or progesterone which are prescribed compounds right i i probably if you looked at my patients probably 60 to 70 percent are on dhea yeah because in women it helps keep testosterone and make testosterone so you can actually have a healthy female testosterone level with just dhea you don't even have to take testosterone necessarily um so and it supports the immune system anti-aging fascinating chemical and it's an inexpensive supplement it's not that expensive at all and it's not that expensive at all and it's it does wonders wonders so we just spent some time talking about labs yeah right but one of the pushbacks i get from guys and gals who are practicing traditional medicine is looking at these guidelines especially acog acog right oh yeah they don't even recommend doing labs for treating women in menopause nams doesn't suggest it either and we're getting into some more technical terms here um but it's important for the audience or the viewers to know because this is the honest dose podcast right but what's going on right i mean we just talked about how important labs could be to figure out what the root cause is right why am i not sleeping why am i so anxious why am i getting this like roll around my midsection why am i snapping at everybody yeah so why do you what why does acog say don't do labs i think we're still sort of stuck on the whole women's health study we're stuck in that old mindset of training um to really understand hormones you really have to dig deep it's a lot of education and so we're looking at fine-tuning and balancing and that is not how we were trained i never learned that in med school yeah and i i think uh with the solution because i get asked this all the time that i've concluded with is you just eloquently explained the symphony including cortisol yeah most dogs don't look at cortisol that closely when they're going through their traditional training they're looking at the estradiol the progesterone the testosterone just looking at those numbers reference ranges it's below i'm going to treat it with that thing because that thing is low because that's ob-gen that's cortisol is the endocrine system yes and thyroid's endocrine system and we learned them in boxes so another subject right endocrinology right we just talked about ob-gyns doing what they have to do then you have endocrinologist right why are they not doing this well you know i think part of it is if you don't really understand how to test cortisol properly you it's a random number and it is a random number but if you can look at them you need the right network of the cells and you don't want to do the same thing every single day so whatever test you take it's it's time-consuming between seven and nine i can tell i don't even have to do a four-point test over 24 hours i can look at you between seven and nine and no are you like going crazy high are you barely blip i can know how much that stress is affecting your body but it's a saliva test that's most accurate a lot of most mainstream doctors have not been trained in saliva testing not just any saliva testing you need a highly reputable reliable lab yep and so you know and then also the only time endocrinologists check cortisol is if they're worried about some sort of pituitary exactly so so this is what i was getting to right the what is if you do look at cortisol right yeah what is the treatment for it oh well you can't you should never give a body steroids right like so traditional medicine says your cortisol is low we're going to give you some steroids that's going to shut it down even further yeah because your body sees this steroid that's why as an anesthesiologist if i have a patient that has taken a big dose of like a prolonged steroid dose in the last year i have to give them a stress dose of steroids a high dose during surgery because the stress their body cannot respond to the stress of surgery intrinsically because taking steroids shut down the production and it takes a while to come back so there's not a medicine to treat that's the answer to your question that was what i was not a medicine to treat cortisol i treat it with supplements i've studied them very carefully they've got specialized ingredients specialized formulas to treat high cortisol versus low completely different takes a long time to fix things and so there's there's no research because there's no medicine exactly so we we we spent a lot of time on figuring out cortisol as being one of the root cause causes for hormone imbalance in general right and finding out that there's not a drug right right that you need to fix that i think is what is at the root cause of why endocrinologists or other doctors don't look at it because what are they going to prescribe or give their patients because in modern medicine when a patient walks into a establishment yeah they're expecting to walk out with the prescription they think there is something that's going to cure them or fix them and that is unfortunately what this today's sick care system as i always call it has led us to all believe we have got away from preventative care and we have got away from preventative care and we have got away from preventative medicine nobody's looking at what to do to avoid things they always want the band-aid approach and for consumers just mentally that is the that's what they're thinking if i don't get something in the mail or i don't get some prescription and a ten dollar copay yeah if i don't get that that means i was not successful in this mission that was on yeah right like even if it's more expensive they're like oh that doesn't work yep so we have trained people to think that way yeah that is i think at the fundamental yeah issue with all this stuff which just kills me sometimes but so tracy we just talked about the woman's health initiative and how one of the outcomes was a 24 increase in breast cancer right that scared a lot of people so if you have a patient coming in and asking you about a if i go on hormones am i going to get breast cancer what's your response my response is no if i'm treating you with a conservative dosing of hormones bio-identical which i am i've taken these hormones for 13 years myself with a strong family history of breast cancer you're that is not going to be an issue now the different people dose different ways you need to be sure the least the most conservative way and that is why no oral estrogen never going to recommend too hard on the body way higher doses than we need we need just enough to get the benefits but not too much that we go on a risk category so it's starting slow

bio-identical most of it always estrogen through the skin we don't replace estrogen until it's low till you're in menopause truly low we don't start throwing it in when you're in perimenopause because you've got spikes up and down in perimenopause then you're going to get in trouble we always have progesterone balancing it yeah and that is why if you ask me am i worried about any risk the answer is absolutely not i've balanced my estrogen with my menopause progesterone i'm doing a very low dose on my skin going straight into tissues i'm testing in the tissues and saliva accurately reflecting because 95 of hormones are bound to proteins in their blood they're not even available so if i'm testing you in blood and i don't test the free hormone which free means it's not bound to a protein so that's only five percent i'm not getting an accurate so and if i give it on the skin and i test in blood i'm going to then overdose you i test in saliva because it's tissues yeah so tracy uh we're trying to do a segment where we have rapid fire questions right it's called the lightning round okay so i'm gonna i'm on a talk show or a quiz show yeah yeah we're trying things out so what's the biggest myth about menopause you want to debunk that you can't take hormones you absolutely can safely take bioidentical compounded hormones love it can women stay on hrt indefinitely absolutely i've been on it 13 years i have no intentions of stopping breast cancer survivors hrt or no that's going to depend that's very much going to depend and you need to be treating in conjunction with a oncologist you need to know hormone markers it's going to be different for everyone best non-hormonal intervention for menopause symptoms um dhea is a supplement it can help boost and and sort of balance hormones and then the secondary there's some herbal things that can help with the vasomotor hot flashes um black cohosh there's some other so there are some herbals if you don't want to go the medication route and they have a few fd approved drugs that just came out just for that they did that recently came out which you can talk about too what's the biggest mistake you see when women start hrt they expect an immediate result and hormones don't work that way they've got to rebalance themselves over a few months and in the process of rebalancing there will be some symptoms yep one supplement every menopausal woman should take can i say two um i i would say hormone or non-hormone are we talking about when supplement non-hormone um dhea okay that's like your favorite yeah it is it's my favorite supplement the other thing would be vitamin d3 oh yeah which is actually not a vitamin but a steroid hormone that has a huge implication for inflammation and mood yeah who knew vitamin d was a steroid hormone right yeah hot take something controversial you believe about woman's health controversial well i believe everyone should be on bhrt and supported through perimenopause into menopause so it's years of support even prior to the actual menopausal event this is a trick question but if you could only optimize one hormone in your body which one would it be oh this is hard cortisol oh i love that answer yeah yeah yeah good biggest difference between treating men versus men is the amount of hormone that you take in your body and the amount of is treating women in longevity medicine women it's a symphony of hormones there's multiple players on the field uh for men it's testosterone for women you've got to balance them all what's next in women's health what should we be excited about the elimination of the black box warning is huge we are now opening conversations about estrogen about hormone replacement therapy the biggest thing that i hope for is that our bioidentical hormones that are compounded are going to be covered by insurance because i think that's the biggest hurdle for us currently i love that thank you tracy i hope it's covered by insurance too at some point that way we can actually get affordable care out to people and i absolutely love the fact that more people are realizing what the whi initiatives did to women's health in general and we're trying to reverse that trend women do deserve better they are starting to be seen more when it comes to menopause and perimenopause and i think we have a lot of work ahead of us but i think exciting times yeah we're in exciting times well i want to thank you for joining us today it's been a pleasure you've shared so much knowledge with us today what if one of our listeners wants to get in touch with you where can they reach you well i'm not i'm kind of a little bit invisible uh so to be to be fully transparent um i do have a newbie instagram account dr tracy neal and um brand new i'm gonna actually out of facebook as well so that we can start sharing some little video clips um so we can get more people to care about our health and we can get more people to little tips, pearls on hormones. And yeah, I'm not, just so you know. You've been invisible. I'm invisible and I'm, you know, I've retired from anesthesia last year. I'm sort of on my way out now, but this passion about wellness for women is still here. Awesome, awesome. Well, thank you, Jerry C., so much for joining us today. Absolutely, it's been a pleasure.

Nimbus Healthcare

See how care connects

Product names mentioned are trademarks of their respective owners. Nimbus Healthcare is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by these companies.

Technology partners

  • NVIDIA Inception Program member
  • Anthropic
  • Braintrust
  • Powered by AWS
  • Twilio
Book a demoFind your path
IntelliHealth® walkthrough